PRETRIAL ADJUDICATION
...Judgment on the Pleadings
......Effect & Timing
10 Cards On This Topic:
  • P moves, D has already answered and time for P to demur to answer expired; D moves, has already answered and time for D to demur to complaint expired.
  • May make motion even though movant demurred to complaint or answer and demurrer overruled, provided there was material change in applicable case law or statute since ruling on demurrer.
  • Motion for judgment on pleadings cannot be made after entry of pretrial conference order or 30 days before initial trial date, whichever is later.
  • Plaintiffs' due process rights violated upon a grant of defendants' motion for JOP after short-noticed Cottle hearing in which plaintiffs failed to make a prima facie showing on their causes of action.
  • Judgment on pleadings for H reversed as judgment that is on appeal is not "final" for purposes of applying the doctrines of claim and issue preclusion.
  • Judgment on pleadings properly granted D after complaint voided for failure to pay fees where statute of limitations ran and P did not state elements for equitable tolling.
  • Motion for judgment on pleadings may be made at any time either prior to or at trial itself, even when general demurrer overruled and previous JPs denied.
  • On a motion for judgment on the pleadings, the complaint cannot be attacked by reference to matters set forth in the answer.
  • Motion for judgment on pleadings may only be made on grounds previously raised by demurrer if material change in case law or statute since time for demurrer.
  • Ct’s grant of motion in limine for nonsuit, though irregular, not procedurally improper, and not judgment on pleadings requiring material change in law or statute; look to ct’s inherent equitable powers.