PRETRIAL ADJUDICATION
...Summary Judgment & Summary Adjudication
......Ruling on Motion
.........Credibility as Factor
6 Cards On This Topic:
  • If party otherwise entitled to SJ, shall not be denied on grounds of credibility of witnesses furnishing affidavits or decls supporting SJ; exceptions.
  • Defendant-employer's motion for summary judgment properly granted where motion could not be denied solely on the basis of the credibility of defendant's primary witness.
  • Although ct. could have refused to accept assertions by D and D’s witness re respective states of mind on D’s motion for SJ, ct. not required to do so.
  • Ct. has discretion to deny SJ on grounds of credibility when only proof of material fact offered in support is affidavit or decl. made by sole witness to such fact.
  • Credibility issue ignored and discretionary power to deny SJ did not apply where proof of all material facts offered by decls of 2 witnesses.
  • In PI case, even if P destroyed credibility of D’s witnesses at trial, he could not prevail against SJ without evidence to connect D corp. with vehicle that struck him.